Dublin Consumers More Cautious Than Elsewhere In Spite Of Better Sentiment In Early 2017

Publication Link
  • Rise in confidence reverses only half of the deterioration felt in Dublin in late 2016
  • Meanwhile, consumer sentiment nears late 2015 highs in the rest of Ireland
  • Household finances healthier than Dublin consumers had feared
  • But worries about economic outlook are notably greater in capital
  • Dublin consumers likely more sensitive to Brexit and Trump related risks as broadening recovery provides offsetting boost in rest of Ireland

Key Data

Consumer Sentiment 1

Analysis by Austin Hughes, Chief Economist, KBC Ireland

The regional breakdown of Irish consumer sentiment data shows a broadly based and similarly scaled increase in confidence across the country in the first quarter of 2017. This largely reflected an improvement in household finances.

However, the details tend to emphasise clear differences in the ways in which consumers in the capital and those in the rest of Ireland see their economic circumstances at present. Dublin consumers have recently become notably more concerned about the general economic outlook than their counterparts in the rest of the country.

In the case of Dublin consumers, the recovery in sentiment in early 2017 only reversed about half of the sharp deterioration seen in the previous quarter, while for consumers outside the capital, recent gains put confidence close to the highs that were seen in late 2015.

Consumer Sentiment 2

In both instances, the latest reading suggests a broadly positive outlook prevails at present, and implies some easing in the worries that marked the late 2016 results. However, the most recent reading suggests Dublin consumers remain notably more cautious than consumers in the rest of the country. We think this reflects a greater sensitivity to external risks to the Irish economic outlook on the part of consumers in the capital. 

The main driver of better consumer sentiment in early 2017 both in Dublin and elsewhere was a less nervous view of household finances. As diagrams 2 and 3 indicate, this improvement reflected healthier readings both in relation to the trend seen through the past twelve months and the outlook for the next twelve months.

Consumer Sentiment 3

As these diagrams suggest, the uptick in areas of personal finances was slightly greater for Dublin consumers than for those in the rest of Ireland. Fears of a sharp worsening in household financial conditions that particularly concerned Dublin consumers in late 2016 have not materialised, prompting a ‘relief rally’ in this element of the survey.

Consumer Sentiment 4

It should be noted that the improvement in consumers’ perceptions of their personal financial circumstances was primarily driven by a drop in the proportion of consumers reporting deteriorating conditions rather than any marked increase in numbers indicating gains in their spending power.

While this implies some easing in ‘feel-bad’, it is unlikely to prompt the emergence of any pronounced ‘feel-good’ factor that would spark notably stronger levels of spending, although the survey suggests some modest recovery in spending plans after a pronounced step back in the previous survey.

Although sentiment improved among Dublin consumers in early 2017, concerns about the economic outlook continued to increase of late. In contrast, there was a slight strengthening of views on the economy on the part of consumers across the rest of the country in recent months. Diagram 4 gives a strong sense of how much consumers in the capital have scaled back their optimism in regard to Irish economic prospects since early 2015.

Consumer Sentiment 5

Our judgement is that a notable change in Dublin consumers’ views of the broader Irish economy initially reflected the failure of a strong recovery in GDP to translate into corresponding gains in the circumstances of the typical household in the capital.

More recently, however, worries about a potentially substantial adverse impact from ‘Brexit’ as well as possible changes in US economic and tax policy may be a particular concern because of the importance of trade and multinational activities to the capital.  

While consumers in other parts of the country are clearly aware of such risks, the direct implications may be less threatening and, in many instances, signs of a broadening of the recovery in domestic spending of late may be have an offsetting impact on their assessment of the economic outlook.

Survey Notes

  • This note describes a breakdown of Irish consumer sentiment into components focussed on Dublin consumers and their counterparts across the rest of Ireland. Data limitations preclude a more detailed breakdown of regions outside of Dublin at this time. Similarly, to ensure sufficient sample size, this breakdown is only possible on a quarterly basis. The starting point of the survey is 2003.
  • The KBC Bank Ireland/ESRI Dublin consumer sentiment index is being released as part of the ‘Dublin Economic Monitor’ by the four Dublin local authorities. The index for the remainder of Ireland is presented for comparative purposes. It is envisaged that a short analysis of the latest trends in consumer sentiment indices for Dublin and the rest of Ireland will be released to coincide with future quarterly releases of the Dublin Economic Monitor.
  • The KBC Bank Ireland/ESRI  consumer sentiment indices for Dublin and the rest of Ireland are quarterly series based on phone interviews with representative samples of consumers over the three months of the relevant quarter. As with the corresponding national survey, these regional sentiment indices are derived from responses given to 5 questions about the outlook for the Irish economy, the outlook for unemployment, recent and expected trends in household finances and the buying climate
  • The data are obtained from telephone interviews during the first two weeks of each month of the quarter. The data are re-weighted in line with gender, age, economic status, level of educational attainment, region and household size to ensure the data was fully representative of the national population of adults. The sentiment index for Dublin is based on approximately 700 responses per quarter. The sentiment index for the rest of Ireland is based on approximately 1700 responses per quarter.

The consumer sentiment index is calculated by computing the relative scores (the percentage of respondents giving favourable replies minus the percentage giving unfavourable replies (the balance), plus 100) for each question used in the different indices. Those who reply “Don’t Know”, “Remain the same” are excluded from the index calculations. Each relative score is rounded to the nearest whole number. The sum of the relative scores is then divided by the base period total for each index.

 

© 2015 The Economic and Social Research Institute. All rights reserved. Website by JET Design